Wednesday Number Ones 3/19/08
Wednesday Number Ones is a weekly feature here at Comic Pants. We take the books that are premiering a first issue from that week and give a quick opinion on them. From time to time we may also include more than issue number ones in this feature. If a noteworthy one-shot or the first issue of a new story arc is released, we may talk about it in this feature.
This week, we will cover Dark Ivory #1, Darkness Vs Eva #1, Everybodys Dead #1, FX #1, Ghost Whisperer #1, Goblin Chronicles #1, Super Friends #1, Tangent Superman’s Reign #1, Tiger & Crane #1, and War Is Hell: First Flight Phantom Eagle #1.
Nick Budd Read and Thought:
Everybody’s Dead #1
Writer: Brian Lynch
Artist: Dave Crosland
Company: IDW Publishing
What would you get if you crossed National Lampoon’s Animal House with Dawn of the Dead? Well, let’s just say the finished product is an odd thing to behold, comical but a little bit clichéd as well. That said, this first issue doesn’t really get into the zombie aspect too much, just a single tease towards the end of it. What it does cover is a over the top but violent feud between two rival fraternities. The humor is well-timed and results in actual laughs, but there’s not a whole heck of a lot too this one, especially since the zombie genre has been literally done to death as of late. As for the art, Crosland does turn in some very expressive, energetic work here. The whole thing has a cartoon-y type feel to it, but every character has a definitive look and a range of emotion to them, which goes a long way to make the characters more likable. Not a bad book, just nothing we haven’t already seen.
Darkness vs. Eva Daughter of Dracula #1
Writers: Leah Moore & John Reppion
Artist: Edgar Salazar
Company: Dynamite Entertainment & Top Cow
Truth be told, I don’t think that I’ve ever read a Darkness story before now. After this little fun-fest, I can sort of see why. It’s not that he’s a boring character, he’s just stuck in boring stories that have been told over and over again. In this crossover, we have vampires and werewolves trying to take over the world and two “heroic” characters, Eva, Dracula’s daughter who wishes to rid the world of all vile and evil things, and Darkness, a quasi gangster that possesses great power, who will undoubtedly fight each other until the inevitable realization that they’re actually both good guys and that they have better things to do. From Leah Moore, Alan Moore’s daughter, I think I was expecting something different and less formulaic. Salazar’s art however, is very solid. The action is well choreographed and easy to follow, and his versions of Darkness’ darklings are specifically cool looking. All in all, kinda boring but fans of the Darkness or Eva might want to give it a shot.
Dave Farabee Read and Thought:
War is Hell: The First Flight of the Phantom Eagle #1 of 5
Writer: Garth Ennis
Artist: Howard Chaykin
Company: Marvel Comics
Raise your hand if you’ve ever heard of Marvel’s World War I flying ace, the Phantom Eagle, before today. Yeah, me neither, but Garth Ennis is pretty much starting from scratch for this Marvel MAX mini, so don’t sweat it. As first issues go, this one’s pretty strong, aided and abetted by Howard Chaykin with some of the best art he’s done in years. I’m betting Howard’s one of these guys who digs sinking his teeth into researching military historical visuals, and it shows. The story introduces us to a Brit flight squadron who find themselves a little rattled when a brash American shows to join them. His backstory and orders seem suspicious and his behavior’s typical of Ennis taking the piss out of Americans while the Brits go about their professional soldiering. Coming from him it’s a bit cliche, but it works on its own terms, and as always his dialogue is hugely readable. Worth checking out for a slightly larger-than-life slice of air combat in The Great War.
Super Friends #1
Writer: Sholly Fisch
Artist: Dario Brizuela
Company: DC Comics
Sporting a nostalgic title and promoting a Mattel line of puffy superhero toys, the first issue of Super Friends is about what you’d expect: cute, kinda fun, definitely aimed at kids, and mildly commercial (Superman can be seen flying a version of that old Superman rocket ship that had the fists on it - no doubt a vehicle in the Mattel toy line). It’s a little like the Lego Star Wars games in tone, and even when the superheroes are on the ropes they somehow manage to be upbeat and smiling. And they defeat Amazo because he’s not yet waterproof and so short circuits when he goes after Aquaman. Geez, even in the kiddie comics they have to strain to find a use for poor Arthur Curry! Needless to say, this one’s strictly for the little ones, but the art’s fun, the story brisk and decent enough. Nothing wrong with that.
Dan Grendell Read and Thought:
Dark Ivory #1
Writers: Joseph Michael Linsner and Eva Hopkins
Artist: Joseph Michael Linsner
Company: Image
Linsner is a talented artist who produces sensual, beautiful paintings. Unfortunately, his interior art is nowhere near as developed, and his writing skills are weaker as well. The addition of longtime art assistant and co-colorist on writing helps, but the story is still a fairly weak one- goth Ivory is full of angst and detached from her family, and wonders what it would be like to be a vampire. Meanwhile, a real vampire wanders the streets, and when Ivory stumbles on one of his victims, she finds herself oddly thrilled. The strongest part of the book is the dialogue, though that sometimes reads unnaturally. The art is generally fairly strong, though there is a scene in the beginning where a woman’s throat is cut deeply open and surprisingly little blood emerges. Overall, this is likely to be of interest to goths and vampire lovers, but few others.
FX #1
Writer: Wayne Osborne
Artist: John Byrne
Company: IDW Publishing
Everybody played pretend when they were kids. You imagined you were in a car and drove around going “VROOM”, or made a gun with you r hand and said “BANG”, or whatever. In FX, young Tom Talbot and his friend Jack are doing just that (though at a bit older age than I remember doing it) when Tom is hit by a glowing light. He soon discovers that when he pretends now, a shape of light appears that really creates what he is thinking about. Fake plane? He can fly. Fake gun? He can shoot. So what does he do? He becomes the superhero FX, of course. This issue he fights the villain gorilla Silverback, though it is never really made clear why such a villain would be incarcerated in a public zoo, and learns that someone knows who he is. A cool, fresh idea, this is some old-school hero fun, and Byrne’s art looks clean and crisp, as good as it has in years. A strong surprise.
The Goblin Chronicles #1 (of 3)
Writers: Troy Dye and Tom Kelesides
Artist: Collin Fogel
Company: APE Entertainment
The races of the Four Realms are at war. Goblin, Elf, Troll, and Shapeshifter all fight each other, and the Dark Queen’s Host takes any leaders prisoner to ensure they never form alliances. But Gorim the Goblin tinkerer has been called along with a representative of the other races to overthrow the Dark Queen and stop the wars. This seems like a fun fantasy quest book, with the standard destined group out to stop the force of evil. The art is a bit rough at the beginning, but already by the end of the book Fogel has improved noticably. Give it a shot, if you like heroic fantasy; I think you’ll dig it.
Randy Lander Read and Thought:
Ghost Whisperer #1
Writer: Becca Smith & Carrie Smith
Artist: Elena Casagrande
Company: IDW Publishing
I don’t know whether this accurately represents the TV show or not, but I do know that the comic at least doesn’t feature any memorable scares, effective atmosphere or any characters with any depth or interesting personality. The story features a hackneyed plot involving mean girls, a tragic death, and a cover-up and weak attempts at Whedon-esque quippy dialogue. The art is somewhat bland and indistinguishable. And the premise, about a woman who helps angry spirits “move on to their final resting place,” never held much interest for me in the first place. I can’t judge how accurately this captures the spirit of the TV show, but I can say that as a comic, it was a disappointment.
Tangent: Superman’s Reign #1 of 12
Writer: Dan Jurgens
Artists: Matthew Clark & Jesse Delperdang
Company: DC Comics
Tangent Comics was an interesting thought-experiment/fifth week event from several years back where creative teams, spearheaded by Dan Jurgens, imagined big names like The Atom, Joker, Superman, Flash and more as new characters, using only the name for inspiration. It was fun, approachable and had some imaginative and entertaining concepts. Unfortunately, this years-too-late sequel of sorts has little of that. Drenched in the same dire “everything sucks” tone that dominates the DC Universe, awkwardly jammed into the new multiverse rather than allowed to stand on its own and drowning in continuity, Tangent: Superman’s Reign is a confusing read with weak art. The colors by Dom Regan range from muddy to garish, Clark’s work is inconsistent and sketchy more often than not and Jurgens doesn’t really explain the characters at all well for those who aren’t intimately familiar with the concept already. Which, at this point, has got to be a fairly small audience.
Tiger & Crane #1
Writers: Alex Leung & Randall Zamchek
Artists: Samicler Goncalves & Aejun
Company: Bluewater Comics
I’m afraid I can’t sugarcoat it… this was pretty bad. Kung-fu superheroics on the streets of San Francisco should be fun and action-packed, but once you get past the shiny colors of Nimmarn Tonglim, you realize that the artwork looks a bit amateurish, with a lot of inconsistency in faces and bodies, sparse and unimaginative backgrounds and dull action that doesn’t convey the flourish that a martial arts comic should have. The story, about a masked vigilante in the Iron Monkey tradition, is a decent premise, but Leung and Zamchek serve up some howlers in the dialogue, making it hard to take the whole thing seriously and yet failing to indicate a tongue-in-cheek tone. The tortured logic of the villain in the opening scene, explaining how a suicide and a disgrace somehow equals his nemesis having killed his family, is ludicrous, put it’s played entirely straight. Which is kind of how I felt about the entire book, to be honest.















So, as far as new number ones go, I’ll be checking out “War is Hell: The First Flight of the Phantom Eagle” and “FX”. It’s good to hear that Byrne’s art is apparently much stronger than usual.
19 Mar 2008 at 5:01 pm
QuoteIf I MAY totally brag for a bit
Yeah I knew who Phatom eagle was I ALSO know he was not always Marvel. He (like Master-man) was a Fawcet character that Marvel brought back before DC brought back Captin Marvel. More properly Phantom eagle was brought back Before CM I think DC just FORGOT master MAN!
ps Yellowjacket is not orginally Marvel etheir but I forget who he was
19 Mar 2008 at 6:28 pm
QuoteI was just wondering if anybody knows what happened to the Killer? I kow the trade is out but I can’t find anything else
19 Mar 2008 at 6:42 pm
QuoteIssues #5-6 came out in the same week a few months back, and are *excellent* reading. We’re still waiting for more.
19 Mar 2008 at 7:17 pm
QuoteWhat’s going on with D3?
Even when he rehashes some things, I still love Ennis’s war stories, so I’m definitely on board Phantom Eagle.
19 Mar 2008 at 7:29 pm
Quote“Grimm Fairy Tales Piper #1″
Is my computer being silly and not loading this, or did you not post a review? Just wondering.
19 Mar 2008 at 8:16 pm
QuoteWhether we review spin-offs of pre-existing lines or not is always a little nebulous, but we were at least planning on covering it until our store sold out before we could get to reviews.
So there ya go. I guess the sell-out kinda counts in its favor, but it’s just one of those things.
19 Mar 2008 at 9:12 pm
QuoteD3’s leg is still caught in a thresher after a dare he foolishly accepted two weeks back. We’re still bringing food to him, but he’s been more interested in extricating his leg than reading comics for whatever reason.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Actually, D3’s just on comics hiatus for a bit, going through the occasional comics overload folks hit sometimes.
19 Mar 2008 at 9:18 pm
QuoteI’ve watched a handful of Ghost Whisperer episodes and the only thing that stands out about it..or I guess hangs out is Jennifer Love Hewitt’s clevage. I guess that along with the female demo is why the show is still going on because it’s pretty much crap.
Hmm I hope JLL or her people don’t see this comment or they might sue me.
19 Mar 2008 at 10:30 pm
QuoteI was thinking the same thing while reading the review — boy, that dame has some nice mams. I can also confirm that the show is otherwise unwatchable. Think “Touched By An Angel” meets “Ghost”, then go take a shower to wash off all the estrogen.
19 Mar 2008 at 10:57 pm
QuotePhantom Eagle is the only one that appeals to me out of that lot (Ennis really excels at war stories) even though my namesake is the artist on the Superman book!
20 Mar 2008 at 4:18 am
QuoteThanks for the explanation- my father always raves about the series (just looks like cheescake to me, but whatever) and was looking forward to a review to find out if it was worth it.
It does make sense that no one reviewed it if there was nothing there to review, though!
20 Mar 2008 at 12:10 pm
QuoteHas anyone been particularly impressed by anything Ms. Moore has written? I’m curious why people assume she has inherited her father’s skills?
Anyway, not a good week for #1s. I didn’t pick up anything and there’s nothing here to change my mind (Ennis and/or war comics aren’t my cup of tea).
20 Mar 2008 at 2:08 pm
Quoteum I GOTTA agree Albion which is all i’ve read by her was just plain no way around it bad
20 Mar 2008 at 2:18 pm
QuoteI don’t know… I guess I’m one of those few people who still remember enough about the Tangent universe to be intrigued by the developments hinted at in this crossover. I can see where others who aren’t familiar with the characters might be confused, but overall, I’m looking forward to seeing where this goes.
20 Mar 2008 at 2:24 pm
Quote“Coming from him it’s a bit cliche”
Coming from a native Irishman, Ennis’ rah-rah British uber alles nationalism is getting a bit creepy. I know he has a real “a plague on both your houses” attitude towards the Troubles, but fuckamagee, that’s not much of an excuse for someone like him to be pledging so much fealty to the crown.
20 Mar 2008 at 2:47 pm
QuoteJust come out and admit you killed him during a Skrull test.
20 Mar 2008 at 9:50 pm
QuoteI’m usually all over any Garth Ennis war stories, as he has an undeniable passion for telling them. What I’m not keen on was the inflated $3.99 price tag for 22 pages of story & art-sheesh!
21 Mar 2008 at 7:36 am
QuoteYeah, I almost picked up FX, but put it back for the same reason. I think $3.00 is something of a mental barrier for me with a regular sized comic. There are certain books like Fables or Walking Dead that I’d be willing to pay more than that for, but once the big companies make their next price jump, I think I’m going to be quitting quite a few books for good.
Man, I feel old when I think back to how I could get 4 comics with my $3.00 weekly allowance back in the 80s.
21 Mar 2008 at 6:29 pm
QuoteI remember when I was buying comics in the ’80s (and even early ’90s) thinking “If it ever gets over $2, I’ll have to stop buying.”
Now the price tag is regularly over $3 (if you count tax) and I don’t even blink an eye. Probably because I’m mostly buying in trade, so I don’t tend to notice the cost per issue ratio as much, but it is kind of funny what you get used to.
I will say, given modern coloring, etc., if you compare a $2.25 comic from the ’90s with almost any $2.99 or $3.50 comic from today, you’re probably going to think the cost to quality ratio is higher… but that just means both books are probably over-priced.
22 Mar 2008 at 10:56 am
Quote