Wednesday Number Ones 4/9/08

numone1.jpgWednesday Number Ones is a weekly feature here at Comic Pants. We take the books that are premiering a first issue from that week and give a quick opinion on them. From time to time we may also include more than issue number ones in this feature. If a noteworthy one-shot or the first issue of a new story arc is released, we may talk about it in this feature.

This week, we will cover Batman Death Mask #1, George R R Martins Wild Cards #1, Number Of The Beast #1, and Titans #1.

Nick Budd Read and Thought:

Titans #1Titans #1
Writer:
Judd Winick
Artist: Ian Churchill
Company: DC Comics

Okay, where to begin with this one? In all seriousness, as much as I was dreading this secondary Teen Titans title (something that still doesn’t make much sense to me), this first issue turned out to be at least readable with a few spots of goodness peppered throughout. Even at his worst, Winick still does have the ability to write good character moments, something that he’s proved in the pages of Green Arrow and The Outsiders, and the same can be said for this book too. His Nightwing and Raven are the standouts, but he’s able to introduce all of the team fairly well, giving each one a fun moment or two while allowing the readers a glimpse at each of their lives outside of superheroics. Still, as good as those character moments are, much of what this story accomplishes and who it presents as the big bad feels like a retread of past Teen Titans continuity, which again makes me ask why there was a demand for this book in the first place. The art, handled by Ian Churchill, is decent enough but often skews into the Top Cow-y like world of unnecessarily big boobies. Still, the otherworldly creatures that the team battle in the issue are inventive looking and fearsome, and the action is quick and fluid. All in all, this one reaches the same heights that Geoff Johns first came onto Teen Titans. If you dug that sort of feel, or just happen to be in the mood for another team book starring the original Titans, this one might be worth checking out.

Dave Farabee Read and Thought:

Batman: Death Mask #1Batman: Death Mask #1 of 4
Writer/Artist:
Yoshinori Natsume
Company: CMX/DC Comics

I didn’t like the cover, but I liked just about everything else. Batman: Death Mask marks one of DC’s periodic forays into combining manga and superheroes, utilizing the talents of actual manga creators. If I’m not mistaken it’s the third or fourth time Batman’s been the subject, but this is the first time I remember being so taken with the “East meets West” blend. In many ways, Yoshinori Natsume’s story is traditionalist, including a quick recap of Batman’s origin (with a great double-page splash of all his villains) and idly posing some of the traditional questions other writers have posed (Does Batman create his own villains? Is age destined to catch up with him?). Two things set it apart, though: First, an Eastern-themed mystery involving Japanese businessmen, mystical masks, and a killer who shares Batman’s silhouette and shears off the faces of his victims (go manga violence!). Second, of course, there’s the unique manga style of storytelling. Even a simple takedown of some muggers in the first few pages crackles with the cinematic energy Japan’s comics are famous for, but quiet scenes are similarly decompressed. For instance, I loved the sequence where Bruce locks eyes with the lone female member of the businessmen’s entourage and, after several beat panels of them staring each other down, strides purposefully towards her (accompanying sound effect for business suit movement: “FWISH!”). For the manga-fearful (I know you’re out there), note that this style of manga art is rooted in the realistic tradition of suspense manga, so don’t worry about being bombarded with the cartoony stuff. Some conventional moments aside, Death Mask is a welcome novelty dotted with any number of remarkable moments. I recommend it and I’m looking forward to the next issue.

Dan Grendell Read and Thought:

Number of the Beast #1Number of the Beast #1 of 8
Writer:
Scott Beatty
Artists: Chris Sprouse and Karl Story
Company: Wildstorm/DC Comics

I’ll be honest. I’ve followed the Wildstorm Universe off and on for years now, and I have a fairly good grasp of it. I’m no expert, but I know the major players and a good number of minor ones. If you haven’t, you will have no idea what the hell is going on in this issue. The key here is two members of an old supergroup from Warren Ellis’s run on StormWatch called the Changers. Both were supposedly dead. One, The High, ran into a forcefield at superspeed, and the book opens with members of Program 666 dumping his living liquid remains into a canister. The other, The Eidolon, was supposedly killed by Rose Tattoo, but shows up here on what seems to be a new world filled with new heroes and villains warning them that “He” is coming and that things are about to change. This is all set-up for what’s to come, but the new heroes, though analogues of existing ones, are fun, and Sprouse and Story do a good job on the art. If you have any interest in the Wildstorm Universe, this is worth checking out; if not, skip it, as you’ll be lost.

Randy Lander Read and Thought:

George R.R. Martin’s Wild Cards #1George R.R. Martin’s Wild Cards #1 of 6
Writer:
Daniel Abraham
Artist: Eric Battle
Company: Dabel Brothers

Newcomers need not apply, I’ll say that right from the start. If you don’t already have some basic knowledge of and appreciation for the Wild Cards anthology novels, I suspect that you’ll find this story of realistic superheroes and supervillains less than friendly, and maybe even a little familiar given how real life elements have slipped into the superhero genre en masse in the last decade or so. However, if you, like me, have read and enjoyed some of the Wild Cards novels, or if you avail yourself of their current reprinting, getting a new story of the Wild Cards universe after some time has passed, with whole new characters and a somewhat updated status quo, is like rediscovering an old favorite. Abraham captures the somewhat moody, occasionally verbose tone of the books perfectly, and the central mystery of a nurse murdered by someone pursuing the virus itself and why they would then use it is a good one that can easily sustain a six issue miniseries. Bonus points for using the Sleeper, the cool Wild Card who gets new powers every time he goes to sleep, as the hard-boiled anti-hero of the piece. Eric Battle’s artwork is not my ideal for this property, a little too uneven in depicting the all-important normal faces and a little bland in imagining Joker’s or the effects of the Black Queen, but with solid enough storytelling to convey the moments. Bottom line, if you’ve ever been a fan of the Wild Cards universe, or if you’re curious enough to check out the novels and find you like it, this comic is a worthy successor to a fondly remembered series of superhero fiction that’s making a welcome return.

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • TwitThis
  • StumbleUpon
  • YahooMyWeb
  • Technorati
  • Furl
  • Ma.gnolia
  • Mixx
  • Reddit
  • E-mail this story to a friend!

Categories: Reviews, Wednesday Number Ones | 13 comments for now

13 Responses to “Wednesday Number Ones 4/9/08”

  1. You know I almost picked up “Batman: Death Mask” when I was in today but since I was disapointed by “Batman-Child Of Dreams” I decided to pass, but after reading the review now I’m kinda sorry I did pass, cause it sounds cool.
    Oh well, as someone who dug the first couple Wild Cards books, though I lost interest around number 3, I did pick up the Wild Card comic at least.

    09 Apr 2008 at 7:24 pm

    Quote
  2. Brian #

    I’ve generally not been a manga fan (but, admittedly, I’ve never really given it a chance). Your review for Batman: Death Mask sounds pretty awesome, though. I think I’m going to pick this up the next time I’m in the shop.

    If I become a manga nut, then it will likely be all your fault. Congratulations, Dave.

    09 Apr 2008 at 7:37 pm

    Quote
  3. Randy Lander #

    Batman: Death Mask was a pleasant surprise. I started out with basically zero interest, because I generally prefer my manga and my superheroes separate (unless DC would release that Wonder Woman manga that was created a while ago by a female cartoonist whose name I’ve forgotten, that looked awesome). But Dave’s positive reaction, and a quick flip-through to look at the art, got me to give it a read, and it was one of my favorite reads of the week. Probably my favorite Batman I’ve read in a while, too.

    09 Apr 2008 at 8:10 pm

    Quote
  4. I’ll start by saying that your Wednesday Number Ones post is one of my favorites among all my feeds. I look forward to it every week. Keep it up!

    Now for this week’s Batman entry, it is on my pull list and based off your review, it looks like I won’t regret it. I’m not a big fan of the typical manga stuff. You know the big eyes, wide mouths and cartoony faces, but reading this:

    For the manga-fearful (I know you’re out there), note that this style of manga art is rooted in the realistic tradition of suspense manga, so don’t worry about being bombarded with the cartoony stuff.

    reminds me a whole lot of one manga I’m currently reading and that I enjoy very much: Naoki Urasawa’s Monster.

    If Yoshinori Natsume’s story holds up well, I’m sure it’ll be a great deal of suspenseful fun.

    09 Apr 2008 at 8:16 pm

    Quote
  5. Bob #

    I don’t know about Batman manga, but that Batman anime that’s coming out later this year looks GREAT.

    09 Apr 2008 at 9:46 pm

    Quote
  6. Joe #

    I was quite excitied about Batman:Death Mask when it was first solicited and I look forward to reading it on Friday.

    Any more thoughts about Titans?

    How was Criminal?

    09 Apr 2008 at 10:40 pm

    Quote
  7. fil #

    I know it is slightly off topic because it is a #1 feature, but the #1 of Ultimates Vol. 3 was rightly bashed (I got it and hated it, too) but I wondered if it improved at all. Anyone pick up any of them? Did they abort the thing in hopes of a better creative team to come along and resurrect it? Should I bring this up Friday?

    10 Apr 2008 at 7:13 pm

    Quote
  8. Dexter Morgan #

    I know it is slightly off topic because it is a #1 feature, but the #1 of Ultimates Vol. 3 was rightly bashed (I got it and hated it, too) but I wondered if it improved at all. Anyone pick up any of them? Did they abort the thing in hopes of a better creative team to come along and resurrect it? Should I bring this up Friday?

    I gave up on it after issue #3 — I don’t like the art and the story is very very dumb. Of all the Panteon members my taste seems most similar to Randy’s — I also share his unabashed Hawkeye love ;-) — so take my opinion for what it’s worth.

    10 Apr 2008 at 10:11 pm

    Quote
  9. fil #

    Dexter, your opinion seems to match mine though I stopped at #1…I just had wondered if it got better. Sometimes comics do that. Sometimes, as it seems with Ultimates, it does not. Light week of #1’s otherwise. I am regretting not getting the Batman manga and may do so if any are left on the ‘previous week’ table next week.

    Hey, will there be a Free Comic Book Day preview this year? That is so helpful when bullying my way around the store to make sure I get the ones I need and not some lame reprint. :-)

    11 Apr 2008 at 10:33 am

    Quote
  10. I was quite excitied about Batman:Death Mask when it was first solicited and I look forward to reading it on Friday.

    Any more thoughts about Titans?

    How was Criminal?

    If you’ve had any level of enjoyment for “Criminal,” this may be the best single issue to date.

    11 Apr 2008 at 5:44 pm

    Quote
  11. Requests for the next issue of W#1:
    ATOMIC ROCKET GROUP 66 #1
    CAPTAIN ACTION #0
    DAMNED PRODIGAL SONS #1
    IRON MAN LEGACY OF DOOM #1
    PERHAPANAUTS #1
    PIGEONS FROM HELL #1
    STAR TREK YEAR FOUR ENTERPRISE EXPERIMENT #1
    WORLDS OF DUNGEONS & DRAGONS #1
    X-MEN DIVIDED WE STAND #1

    I know nothing about the first three, want to know if the Iron Man story is worthwhile, and am curious about Perhapanauts.

    Pigeons From Hell! The title alone is AWESOME!

    ST:Y4:EE is part of the new line of ST series from IDW, but I’m wondering if it’s any good, or at all worthwhile for someone who doesn’t read much ST fiction.

    What’s this D&D title? Is it a tribute of sorts to Gygax?

    And is XM:DWS worthwhile? Legacy, X-Force, and Young X-Men have been letdowns. None worth the price of admission. How about THIS one?

    14 Apr 2008 at 5:08 pm

    Quote
  12. Alan Coil #

    I finally read Wild Cards. “NO N00BS ALLOWED” might as well be the title. The back story of Wild Cards is too deep and complex to be summed up in a few pages. I, too, loved that they use Croyd.

    As for the art, at least it isn’t Brett Booth, who did the Anita Blake book, and will be doing the Koontz Frankenstein book. And in any case, it would be near impossible for any artist to draw the characters the way I see them in my mind when I read the books. This was a problem (minor problem) in the Marvel series a few years ago.

    I liked the first issue and have hopes that the story will hold together.

    14 Apr 2008 at 7:00 pm

    Quote
  13. Randy Lander #

    ATOMIC ROCKET GROUP 66 #1

    Could swear we’d ordered this, but it’s not coming in next week.

    CAPTAIN ACTION #0

    Won’t be in the reviews.

    The rest, plus Cthulhu Tales #1, Dc Wildstorm Dreamwar #1, Jim Butchers Dresden Files #1 and Noble Causes #32 (It’s pretty much a first issue, just doesn’t have a #1) should be in the Wednesday Number Ones feature for this week.

    15 Apr 2008 at 12:59 am

    Quote

Comments RSS

Leave a Reply

XHTML: You can use these tags: [spoiler] <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>